| Platinum | Firey Pig |
| Gold | Mimi's Cafe |
| Silver | Metro Diner |
| Bronze | Sylvan Park Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Boro Bowls |
| Top Pick | Fried Tater Cafe |
| Top Pick | Goodness Gracious Cafe and Catering |
| Top Pick | Joanie's Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Simply Pure Sweets |
| Top Pick | Waffle House |