| Platinum | Firey Pig |
| Gold | Busy Bee Cafe Lascassas |
| Silver | Toot's Restaurant |
| Bronze | The Chop House |
| Top Pick | Boro Bourbon & Brews |
| Top Pick | Boro Kabob |
| Top Pick | Jim 'N Nick's Bar-B-Q |
| Top Pick | Mimi's Cafe |
| Top Pick | Slick Pig BBQ |
| Top Pick | The Alley On Main |
| Luca's Pizzeria | |
| Tasty Table Event Catering |