| Platinum | Camino Real Mexican Restaurant |
| Gold | Chuy's |
| Silver | Casa Adobe Express |
| Bronze | Taqueria Lupita |
| Top Pick | Chagos |
| Top Pick | Cinco De Mayo Mexican Restaurant Murfreesboro |
| Top Pick | LA Siesta Mexican Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Mi Patria |
| Top Pick | Tequila's Mexican Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Tijuana Flats |
| El Toro Mexican Restaurant |